American-style Cheesecake

Cheesecake in Germany is different. It’s good, but it’s far lighter and crumblier than American cheesecake, with nowhere near the tangy flavor I expect. I’ve tried to make cheesecake over here before, but it never quite works out correctly. The flavor is always somewhat lacking and the texture is a little off. I’m certain it has to do with availability of ingredients. The cream cheese here is all spreadable – they don’t seem to have the big, dense blocks of Philly, wrapped in foil, that have to sit out and soften on the counter before you can put it in the mixer. Even if I could get the blocks (and I probably could – I have ways), I really don’t have the fridge space to store it.

While planning Thanksgiving desserts with our friends, we decided a cheesecake might be in order (counterpoint to the omnipresent pies). So I started my usual recipe search, when I had an idea; look for a German-language recipe for ‘American’ cheesecake! I found a winner here. The original recipe is in German with metric measurements, but here’s my translation.

25-30 Leibniz wholegrain (vollkorn) cookies, crushed
5-6 T (80 g) butter, melted

17 oz (500 g) cream cheese ((Edited on 2018-04-30; a previous incarnation of this recipe had the cream cheese-to-quark ratio flipped. This way (as written here, now) is even better.))
14 oz (400 g) quark cheese
3/4 c (160 g) sugar
1 1/2 t vanilla extract (wanna be fancy? Scrape a whole vanilla bean instead)
3 eggs
1 pinch salt

1 large jar sour cherries (Schattenmorellen)
2 T cornstarch

Preheat oven to 350°F/170°C.

Mix the crushed cookies and melted butter together in a bowl, until all the crumbs are evenly moistened and are starting to clump. Press the crumbs into the bottom of a 24-26 cm. springform pan until they make an even layer.

In a large mixer bowl, combine all the filling ingredients and beat until smooth and light. Pour into the springform and bake for at 40 minutes or until the center is somewhat jiggly, but no longer liquidy. I prefer to bake mine a little longer, until the top is no longer shiny – but this will probably cause your cake to crack. Allow cake to cool to room temperature, then chill for at least 4 hours, preferably overnight.

The topping is optional, but I like my cheesecake with cherries. Into a small saucepan, drain your cherry juice and set cherries aside for now. Put 4-5 T of the cherry juice in a small glass or measuring cup and add the cornstarch, stirring well. Bring the juice in the saucepan to a boil, then add the cornstarch slurry while stirring. The mixture will immediately thicken. Remove it from the heat, stir in the cherries and serve with the cheesecake.

3 thoughts on “American-style Cheesecake”

  1. Tiffany @ No Ordinary Homestead

    I’ve never had much trouble with the ingredients aside from the crust…so I just make it with Oreos. Sure it’s a whole lot more calories thrown in there, but hey, it’s cheesecake after all. This version sounds at least a little bit more healthy than the one I make since it’s got quark…but where would the fun be?

    And Käsekuchen — yeah, not even close :)

    Did you make this with your new KitchenAid? ;)

    1. Sarah

      The cheesecakes I’ve made previously were perfectly good from an objective standpoint, they just weren’t what I had in mind. And I have almost no experience with quark, so I didn’t notice any unwanted ‘healthy’ aspects of the finished product. I was just mostly excited that the flavor was what I expected and the top (miraculously!) didn’t brown.

      I was lazy, so I didn’t use the KitchenAid – after the Thanksgiving cooking blowout, I couldn’t bear to wash more than the beaters on my hand mixer. But next time, it’s KitchenAid all the way!

  2. Dutch Baby - Regensblog

    […] of jam you like… I opted for a cherry sauce with Schattenmorellen taken from Sarah’s American-style Cheesecake recipe. […]

What's your take on it?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.